Showing posts with label Qur'an. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Qur'an. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 28, 2017

Gendered Scripture


            Reading into the 97th Sura (Al-Qadr) was my first attempt to deeply comprehend and attempt to register the complexity of the interpretation of the Qua’ran. Interpreters of the are split on whether “qadr” should be translated as “Destiny” or “Power” as well as whether or not it is definitely a Meccan sura. Discovering the heated debates around where and when each sura was revealed to Mohammad and learning a bit about his migration and followers, I tried not to just draw parallels to the Bible.
            The more I learned about even this piece of the Qua’ran, the more similarities and differences between what I read and know about how the Bible was conceived occurred to me. This particular sura was revealed on one of the last nights of Ramadam, probably the 27th night when the fasting was ending. This is generally a celebration and reflection on the journey of Ramadam and is also a night that is a child’s first attempt at fasting. Worshippers may stay up all night to pray or meditate. The divine and human are close to one another, so Al-Qadr is one of the most mystical nights.

            The biggest difference in this holy scripture for me, however, came with the gendered text. The gender dynamic of the Qur’an is found in this sura:
We sent him* down on the night of destiny.
and what can tell you of the night of destiny
The Night of Destiny is better than a thousand months. 
The angels come down, with the spirit upon it by permission of their lord, from every order.
Peace she is until the rise of dawn.
            The him in the first iyat is supposed to refer to the Qur’an, as it was revealed to Mohammad. The “her” is the Night; this amazing happening is referred to as feminine in this very masculine religion. This is personification, and when, at the center of the sura, the angels come down on “it,” this could be the Spirit, the Quar’an, or the night being inseminated. The insemination of the night, Sells, argues, is parallel to Mary being divinely inseminated and becoming pregnant with Jesus. However, since the personification is not “complete,” translators do not feel completely sure. I feel much the same way, but it makes me wonder more about the translation and interpretation of the Bible across language in a new way.

Narrative

At the conference last week, there were many different papers that had come from a seminar on the Apostle Paul. They all worked to reinterpret Paul's work for the modern age, focusing on how he applies to concepts like islamophobia and environmentalism. He is an interesting figure for sure, first bashing Christianity as a Jew, then converting and bashing Judaism. Current scholarship is working on reinterpreting him, and this is a phenomena that we also encountered in our study of the Torah and the role of women in Half the Kingdom. I think this is a hugely worthwhile action- we must update and adapt our understandings of these texts to keep them relevant and informative in the framework of our modern world. This occurs in Islam as well: As we saw with the Imam last week, Qur'an interpretation changes to add inclusivity over time as well. The discussion of the gender fluidity was a fantastic example of thought changing and adapting over time. We are constantly reframing context as we gain more information, forgetting that which needs to be left in the past to move forward.

I wonder where alternate texts come into this conversation. We are editing historical narratives, but what happens if we look for alternate narratives based off the work that history has forgotten? Or what happens if we acknowledge all the other influences that the past has had. For example, so much of popular understanding of Christianity comes from Paradise Lost, but no one addresses this.

We discussed narratives at the conference, and it has clearly got me thinking about the narratives we engage with in class.

Image result for paradise lost

Sunday, March 19, 2017

Up to Interpretation?


            According to Tariq Ramadan’s New York Times article, the Quar’an acts like a bridge between an individual Muslim and the creator. It is the word of God. Through the text, God is speaking to the individual and the individual’s values and individual Islamic values. In Christianity, I feel like God is sending a message through the Bible. This message is then supported by many examples, which reinforce the message. These are meant to be deciphered by God’s followers, but have been used for many different reasons.
            Although the Qur’an is God speaking directly to all Muslims, it is accepted that the readings can be interpreted and have meaning for an individual, just as Christianity generally believes and some Jewish sects suppose. Additionally, when Muslims interpret God’s message and the content of the Qua’ran, the interpretations embody and engulf the ethics and the moral values of Islam as a whole, which is similar to the Judeo-Christian tradition, as I understand it.
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh_B5YBCMk5n5xeEO9qHAmLFauurYK0OVmGmDzS0uy1kei7RVrk6343-64B53I6W_nMVT8lRAF9u23aBFKV0RSqhMeICYevhHLd-WBAYFBnSNHdE9doCo3TNfdnx3eLSsaw0ifK54Rhvlf8/s1600/Quran+Bible.jpg
            As a “good” Christian or Muslim, a follower is expected to take the values God gives—communicated through Scripture—and use them positively in his or her life.
            The Qua’ran, so far, sounds more concrete. The message seems less flexible, stronger and MUST be followed than what I have learned of the Torah and Bible. I do not yet know whether or not this is a product of my understanding of people who are culturally associated with Muslim countries, as I am more familiar with Judeo-Christian theologies and cultures. With this in mind, it seems to me that as world views progress, interpretations of both the Bible and the Torah are more flexible than those of the Qua’ran.

Friday, March 10, 2017

To Open

As I was looking at the opening prayer of the Qur'an, I realized that people have a tendency to say something when every they begin something new. Its like the ribbon cutting at a new store or building. There is this whole routine that occurs before the store is opened. First there are speeches and there are toasts and often a party or something of the kind. It ends with the ribbon being cut and then the store opens. It does not matter what the store or building is, there is almost always this ceremony at the beginning. I realized that this is very similar to the start of prayer service, whether Jewish or Islamic. For Jews, services always start with the Shema, or the call to service. It does not matter what Torah portion is being read that day, the Shema is always chanted at the start. The same seems true for Islamic prayer service. They always begin with the prayer The Opening.
Image result for ribbon cutting ceremony
The need to start off anything with a consistent opening is not just held to ceremonies of warship. People usually start most things in life with a consistent routine. Most people will start each day with the same routine, such as brushing their teeth. The need to start the unfamiliar with the familiar is very strong and is a part of our lives, whether in just daily life or in prayer.