Showing posts with label Judaism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Judaism. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 28, 2017

Narrative

At the conference last week, there were many different papers that had come from a seminar on the Apostle Paul. They all worked to reinterpret Paul's work for the modern age, focusing on how he applies to concepts like islamophobia and environmentalism. He is an interesting figure for sure, first bashing Christianity as a Jew, then converting and bashing Judaism. Current scholarship is working on reinterpreting him, and this is a phenomena that we also encountered in our study of the Torah and the role of women in Half the Kingdom. I think this is a hugely worthwhile action- we must update and adapt our understandings of these texts to keep them relevant and informative in the framework of our modern world. This occurs in Islam as well: As we saw with the Imam last week, Qur'an interpretation changes to add inclusivity over time as well. The discussion of the gender fluidity was a fantastic example of thought changing and adapting over time. We are constantly reframing context as we gain more information, forgetting that which needs to be left in the past to move forward.

I wonder where alternate texts come into this conversation. We are editing historical narratives, but what happens if we look for alternate narratives based off the work that history has forgotten? Or what happens if we acknowledge all the other influences that the past has had. For example, so much of popular understanding of Christianity comes from Paradise Lost, but no one addresses this.

We discussed narratives at the conference, and it has clearly got me thinking about the narratives we engage with in class.

Image result for paradise lost

Sunday, March 19, 2017

Up to Interpretation?


            According to Tariq Ramadan’s New York Times article, the Quar’an acts like a bridge between an individual Muslim and the creator. It is the word of God. Through the text, God is speaking to the individual and the individual’s values and individual Islamic values. In Christianity, I feel like God is sending a message through the Bible. This message is then supported by many examples, which reinforce the message. These are meant to be deciphered by God’s followers, but have been used for many different reasons.
            Although the Qur’an is God speaking directly to all Muslims, it is accepted that the readings can be interpreted and have meaning for an individual, just as Christianity generally believes and some Jewish sects suppose. Additionally, when Muslims interpret God’s message and the content of the Qua’ran, the interpretations embody and engulf the ethics and the moral values of Islam as a whole, which is similar to the Judeo-Christian tradition, as I understand it.
https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEh_B5YBCMk5n5xeEO9qHAmLFauurYK0OVmGmDzS0uy1kei7RVrk6343-64B53I6W_nMVT8lRAF9u23aBFKV0RSqhMeICYevhHLd-WBAYFBnSNHdE9doCo3TNfdnx3eLSsaw0ifK54Rhvlf8/s1600/Quran+Bible.jpg
            As a “good” Christian or Muslim, a follower is expected to take the values God gives—communicated through Scripture—and use them positively in his or her life.
            The Qua’ran, so far, sounds more concrete. The message seems less flexible, stronger and MUST be followed than what I have learned of the Torah and Bible. I do not yet know whether or not this is a product of my understanding of people who are culturally associated with Muslim countries, as I am more familiar with Judeo-Christian theologies and cultures. With this in mind, it seems to me that as world views progress, interpretations of both the Bible and the Torah are more flexible than those of the Qua’ran.

Wednesday, March 1, 2017

Midrash and Play: The Torah as Transitional and Transformational Object

It occurs to me that midrash is a way of playing with the Torah to address a kind of attachment disturbance between the Jewish people and God, between me personally and God. Two things got me thinking about midrash and Torah this way.  First was Avivah Zornberg's suggestion in her commentary on the book of Exodus that the Torah is both a transitional object and a transformational object. Infants and children carry, embrace, and fondle something that is a kind of "piece" of their mother whose feel, smell, or sight of reminds them of their mother when she is away.  By holding and playing with this transitional object, they can hold it together when they are separated from their significant other. Like Linus' blanket in Peanuts.  But also like Linus, when he plays with his blanket, he can transform it, in the process be himself transformed as his play gives him space to grow and develop his independence, even play at being a kind of grown-up himself.


With a transitional object, we maintain the attachment of love, affection, being cared for that we need to thrive and grow, but also the separation from our significant care-giving other that we also need to thrive and grow into our own.  The creative pre-occupation involve in playing with with our transitional/transformational object makes us both remember and forget the trauma of separation we feel.

Second was the parable of the ketubbah we studied.  It also makes this point about the importance of playing with a transitional object, and specifically applies it to scripture as being the object that makes the very painful separation of God from the people of Israel bearable, just as holding, fondling, reading the ketubbah and the promises of everlasting love and devotion enable the wife to bear her separation from her beloved husband. By playing with it, engaging in it, we can evoke the feelings of being with our parent or lover as if he were still there, even though we know very well he is not.  As our spiteful neighbors remind us.  And interestingly enough, both Zornberg's commentary on the Exodus passages, and the parable of the ketubbah in Lamentations Rabbah punctuate their interpretations with the same verse from Psalms: "If your Torah had not been my delight (or "plaything"), I would have perished my affliction." (119:92). Midrash turns Torah into something we can, we must play with to keep alive our affection for its source, but also to grow and adapt with our "plaything" to new situations without being suffocated by the love of our significant, formative parental Other.  We need space to play and grow, but we need also to feel loved and cared for as we carve out that space for ourselves, or when life's circumstances inevitably separate us from those who love us and vice versa.  We still can connect.  So yes, "If your Torah had not been my delight (or "plaything"), I would have perished my affliction."

And "THIS I call to mind and therefore I have hope." (Lam 3:20) 


Thursday, February 9, 2017

Now vs. Then

Having read the Hebrew bible again recently, I am reminded that the way the we were told to do things like celebrate were different from the way we celebrate now.many of the celebrations the Jewish people were told to have are still celebrated today but in a different way.
Image result for passover
Passover is one of the celebrations that has changed and evolved over time. In the bible we are told to celebrate the freeing of the Hebrews from Egypt but we are only told this in vague terms, "For seven days you are to eat bread made without yeast." (Exodus 12:15). Now, however, we celebrate this with Passover. Passover is a seven night celebration of the freeing of the Hebrews. Many of the things we are asked to do in the bible are the same today, such as during Passover, we only eat unleavened bread. But many things have been added. One addition is to leave out a cup of wine for the prophet Elijah and leave a door cracked open so he may enter the house. another addition to the celebration is reciting of the words of the four children.
Image result for shabbat
Another celebration that has changed is Shabbat. Shabbat is the celebration of the Sabbath on Friday nights. In the Bible we are told to rest and not do any work on the Sabbath, "but the seventh day is a sabbath to the LORD your God. On it you shall not do any work, neither you, nor your son or daughter, nor your male or female servant, nor your animals, nor any foreigner residing in your towns" (Exodus 20:10). The way the sabbath is celebrated is very different. We still do no work, but we have a special dinner to celebrate the sabbath. We eat a special bread called challah, and we light candles and drink a ceremonial cup of wine.


We have thousands of years of history and that has caused us to change the way we partake the celebrations and ceremonies described in the bible. It gives one the feeling of being involved in the way we interpret the bible.

Tuesday, February 7, 2017

Whose narrative? Repetition and non-repetition of Pharaoh's hardened heart, in the Torah and now

The original experience of the signs and miracles may have been overwhelming.  But when the Torah repeatedly urges their transmission to the future, in the form of narrative, triumphant simplicities disappear in the dazzle and blur of memory. The question arises: "Whose narrative?"   (Avivah Zornberg, The Particulars of Rapture: Reflections on Exodus)

I have been thinking a lot lately about how one deals with people who seem impervious to communication or paying attention to data that might change their minds, or as the Torah puts it, whose "hearts are hardened."  Last week, the weekly Torah portion read in Jewish synagogues was chapters 10-13 of Exodus, which covers the last few plagues when Pharaoh's heart is hardened, explicitly by God, as well as the first Passover laws intended to keep the Israelites from suffering the plague of the death of the firstborn. Among these laws is the command to tell this story to future generations of Israelites. Avivah Zornberg, in her commentary to Exodus,  discusses this, and suggests that the Biblical narrative includes a kind of subversive subtext of narrative, a way of saying you shouldn't necessarily believe exactly what your eyes have seen (or what your ears have heard).  There might be multiple ways of interpreting the events before your eyes - the signs and wonders God accomplished in the Egyptians and Israelites, right before their eyes.  Though not right before the eyes of subsequent generations of Israelites, that is, "your child who will ask" what the laws instituted in Ex 12-13 mean.  The narrative non-repetitions in the story of the plagues open other possible interpretations.

There are discrepancies and non-repetitions in what, how, and why God says specifically about Pharoah's heart being hardened. In Ex. 7:3-5, the Lord says:
But I will harden Pharaoh’s heart, and I will multiply my signs and wonders in the land of Egypt. 4 When Pharaoh does not listen to you, I will lay my hand upon Egypt and bring my people the Israelites, company by company, out of the land of Egypt by great acts of judgment. 5 The Egyptians shall know that I am the Lord, when I stretch out my hand against Egypt and bring the Israelites out from among them.

In Ex. 10:12, before the 8th plague of the locusts, the Lord says,
Go to Pharaoh; for I have hardened his heart and the heart of his officials, in order that I may show these signs of mine among them, 2 and that you may tell your children and grandchildren how I have made fools of the Egyptians and what signs I have done among them—so that you may know that I am the Lord.
It's not just for the Egyptians to to know, but also so that you - Israelites, including your children and grandchildren- "may know that I am the Lord" - by telling them how He made fools of the Egyptians.
Not exactly what God said earlier.

Moreover, did God Himself harden Pharaoh's heart, or did he harden it himself?  Certainly God predicts that he will harden Pharaoh's heart, but does that mean that God was directly responsible for every instance that Pharaoh's heart was hardened?  The narrative offers a mixed message: sometime Pharaoh himself, sometimes God hardened it. For the first five plagues, it seems to be Pharaoh himself. Pharaoh is the subject of sentences referring to his hardening his heart; it doesn't say explicitly God hardened it, i.e., 7:22: after the blood plague, "Pharaoh remained obstinate (as the Lord had foretold)"; after the frogs, "he became obdurate  as the Lord had foretold;" after the lice, 8:19: "Pharaoh remained obstinate  (as the Lord had foretold); and so on after the swarms of flies (8:32),  the plague of the animal disease (9:12). Only after the plague of hail, while at first it says Pharoah remained obstinate (9:35), does it say explicitly (with God speaking), that "I have made him [Pharaoh] and his courtiers obdurate" (Ex 10:1), and then after the plague of locusts, "The Lord made Pharaoh obstinate" (10:20), after the plague of darkness, " "the Lord made Pharaoh obstinate" (10:27; 11:9).

So does this break in the pattern suggest that Pharaoh at least at first had free will, and only later did God make him harden his heart?  Or did God's foretelling it make it so, as a sort of self-fulfilling prophecy? The non-repetition makes us question who's pulling Pharaoh's strings, or when?  Also, in several of Pharaoh's refusals to let the Israelites go, he first assents (sometimes with conditions unacceptable to Moses), and then changes his mind.  That sounds more like a flexible, rubbery heart, not an inflexible heart of stone - despite the fact the text says Pharaoh's heart was "hardened."

So this is one set of particularly significant breaks from the repeated pattern of "plague followed by Pharaoh's heart-hardening." This break also parallels more or less another break - plagues affecting all of Egypt, vs. plagues specified as affecting only the Egyptians, and sparing the the Israelites.  That sets up the last big break from the pattern, God's legislation of the Passover laws in Ex 12 between the 9th and last plague killing the Egyptians' first born sons.  By observing those laws, by doing that actions commanded by God, the Israelites will be be spared from the fate of having their first born sons killed unlike the Egyptians; God will "pass over" the Israelites' homes. An interesting and notable connection between narrative and law in the Torah! The laws have a function in the narrative - to break the pattern and to advance the plot!

OK - so much for the details. The big question is what's the point of these repetitions and breaking the pattern? I think it's to address the the bigger question, the one I began with - how do we explain and how do we deal with people like Pharaoh who are impervious to persuasion and change, and who seek to harm us? The Torah "answers" this by basically having God set Pharaoh up, staging a performance in which Pharaoh thinks and acts as if he's in control, but he's really not.  God plays him like a puppet, and shows him to be a self-deluded fool before the eyes of his Egyptian subjects, and before the eyes of the Israelites.  Pharaoh doesn't really ever have to be convinced decisively to change his mind, since he is overcome by events, regardless of his intentions.  God uses Pharaoh's  intransigence to make a point,  a point made not only to the the Egyptians and Israelites at the time, but to subsequent generations of Israelites, by commanding the Israelites to tell and retell the story of what God did for them and to Pharaoh and the Egyptians.

But at what cost?  A lot of innocent Egyptians had to suffer because of the hard-heartedness of their ruler; their animals and land devastated, a lot of dead first-born sons! All to make a point!? What kind of God does this?  What kind of  people worship and serve a God who would do this?  The narrative raises as many questions as it "answers." The holes in the narrative, the discrepancies, the repetition/non-repetitions leave room for these questions.  And so does the command to tell the story in subsequent generations, because each retelling has to confront anew these questions, gaps, discrepancies.  We see and embrace both the patterns and the breaks from the patterns.   The Torah text leaves room for subversive narratives, different ways of telling "the same story."

And the new circumstances in which we retell the old stories also bring out new resonances, new meanings. What do you think of now, when you hear the story of the heart-hardened Pharaoh, impervious to persuasion, to facts, to the advice of his advisors, to the suffering of his own subjects, and to the suffering of the Others in his midst?



Negativity Scene

Instead of a Christmas card this year, I was sent a "Negativity" Scene card by my friend.
"He doesn't look THAT special"

Initially, I was struck simply by her ability to comment on the human condition and clever wordplay. However, since beginning this class, this card has taken on a different meaning.

The thing is, the Bible is an incredibly negative place, on many different levels. Adam and Eve are cast out of the garden, and the entirety of human existence is based on an finding escape from suffering (the afterlife). It is Marx who hypothesized that religion is humanity's response to suffering, so if we eliminate suffering, then the false consciousness of religion will fade away. The varied forms of religion, and its pervasiveness show the false nature of this hypothesis, but the undercurrent of the relationship between humanity and suffering, and understanding its function still stands when reading the Bible. Suffering ruled the people of this time, and they fought a daily struggle for existence. It is no wonder that God is embodied among them, in the rain and the harvest and drought and famine. This is where the ritual comes in, to mediate this interaction. Ritual is embodied religion, and there is no clearer example then sacrifices that God outlines for his subjects.

However, it is worth noting that negativity behaves differently here, once we begin to talk about God and humanity together: (this may be a slightly controversial statement, but I believe this) the entire dualistic relationship is based on the inherent lack in humanity. If God is all powerful, then humans must lack power. If God is all knowing, then humanity lacks a kind of knowing. If God is holy, then humanity is all sinners.  This is the general way that the relationship manifests- through a negative identity in humanity. However, the Bible also offers a counterpart to this relationship, as seen in Leviticus. It is the God-among-us idea. This helps to de-rigidify the dualisms that this negativity has created through the material nature of the world, because God's power is intermingled with humanity's and humanity becomes powerful through their ritual interactions with God. Laws exist as God's will in materiality

Scripture can be read in a multitude of ways, as we have been discussing. I think the focus on this interaction through ritual is a beneficial one to reframe the interactions we have with God, based in our material and embodied reality and maintaining the agency of humanity in the divine game.